A mother, father and son with though bubbles containing images of Buffalo school building surrounding them.

School Choice Creates the Tragedy of the Commons

BY SIMONE A. FRIED

In 1968, ecologist Garrett Hardin published a landmark paper about how individuals make decisions about shared resources like clean air. Termed the tragedy of the commons, Hardin’s theory explains how, as individuals naturally tend to prioritize their own interests, their micro-decisions over time destroy the shared resources.

Today another shared resource is falling prey to Hardin’s predictions: U.S. public schools. School choice policies were created to reduce segregation and empower families to select their best fitting school. But research reveals problems with the market-based theory of choice. Especially in larger urban areas like Buffalo, where my research team studies choice policy in partnership with the Western New York Education Equity Task Force and the Buffalo Public Schools (BPS), these assumptions don’t hold up. By putting families in competition, choice policies create tragedy in our common schools.

My team’s analysis of BPS lottery data shows that nearly half of BPS elementary students receive none of their school choices. More than half of families—especially white families in wealthier neighborhoods—apply only to BPS’s few high-performing criteria-based schools, and if they are not accepted, many leave for private schools, charters or suburban districts. Other families remain stuck in less desired schools and often face long, uncertain journeys of reapplication and advocacy. There are schools no families choose, and these schools are not evenly distributed geographically, but coincide with race- and class-based residential segregation in Buffalo.

“There are schools no families choose, and these schools are not evenly distributed geographically, but coincide with race- and class-based residential segregation in Buffalo.”

―Simone Fried

Interviewing families, we learned about choice’s hidden costs, which echo research conducted elsewhere. Parents described heavy burdens navigating complex school selection processes, leaving them less time and energy to develop local relationships or volunteer at school. While some highly engaged parents intentionally chose schools outside their neighborhood, many more wanted a safe, high-quality school close to home, and struggled to understand how to achieve it.

For school districts, too, choice carries costs: skyrocketing transportation budgets, keeping families informed, managing complex registration processes, declining enrollment that reduces the available funding for improvement, and disrupted governance. That is, parents can keep voting in districts where their kids aren’t registered, exercising their privilege to influence decisions that will not affect their privately educated children while often criticizing parents and educators who remain in public schools. Another way choice disrupts governance is that when children attend school outside their residential voting subdistrict, their parents are unable to cast a vote for the board member that represents their school, eroding accountability.

Choice is in the news as states like Texas enact sweeping voucher laws. But we should be cautious of the costs. Under choice, the easiest path for everyone is to neglect our responsibility to the collective. By dividing schools into winners and losers, choice models subtly shift the burden of responsibility for children’s success away from the system to guarantee quality seats to every child, and onto families for “choosing well,” distracting from the need for substantive school improvement.

That’s what makes it tragic. Choice systems benefit some individuals, but they also make it harder for local schools to become flourishing centers of community. Harder for parents to learn from each other and develop relationships with educators; harder, too, for students to sustain neighborhood friendships and a home-school connection. The costs may be worthwhile if they enable children to access better choices, but otherwise they are tough to justify.

I don’t suggest eliminating choice without confronting the equity issues it was intended to address. For one thing, it would be hypocritical. I attended private schools and can’t criticize other families for seizing similar opportunities. All families deserve agency and access to quality schools. But families also deserve a public school system that sustains, rather than depletes, itself.

As my team continues our research, I am grateful to the BPS leaders who have welcomed us, and hopeful that we can identify policies that help families act to benefit both themselves and their commons. That is, what would be needed—and specifically, what reinvestments in which neighborhoods—for more families to prefer their local school?

Simone Fried.

Simone A. Fried is an assistant professor in the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy with research expertise in school district policy implementation, governance and administration and research-practice partnerships.