Q&A

Who is flying the plane?

Karly Rakhim’s research shows how international doctoral students are using generative AI as a tool, support system and source of tension in academic life.

INTERVIEW BY DANIELLE LEGARE

Illustration of the cockpit of a plane with controls visible and a view of UB South Campus. | This image is AI generated.

This image is AI generated.

Autopilot is standard in modern aviation. Yet pilots are still required to master manual flight, especially for takeoff and landing, when everything is at stake. Since late 2022, generative AI has become the autopilot across higher education. Karly Rakhim wanted to know what that shift means for international doctoral students, who are already learning to fly in unfamiliar airspace.

Rakhim, an international doctoral student from Kazakhstan and a Presidential Fellow in GSE’s higher education PhD program, became interested in the topic as generative AI tools rapidly became woven into academic life. Her research asks how the use of generative AI shapes international doctoral students’ scholarly identity and how it affects their emotional well-being.

In an IRB-approved qualitative research project, Rakhim interviewed 15 international doctoral students from nine countries at three research institutions. Most participants also shared artifacts, such as prompts, written work, visual projects or problem-solving examples, to show how they used AI in their academic and personal lives.

What did your research reveal about how international doctoral students are using generative AI in their academic lives?

Students used generative AI across the entire academic day: translating dense readings, checking grammar, brainstorming ideas, summarizing literature, drafting emails and working through code. What stood out was how they described its role. Ananya called it “an assistant, but where I am still the leader.” Vikram described it as “another advisor.” Roya said it felt like “a weekly meeting” with a colleague she could return to.

Students described AI as helpful and, at the same time, unsettling. What did that tension look like?

Emotional dissonance showed up in almost every interview. Doctoral students felt mixed emotions during a single task. Many felt proud or relieved to have completed something, yet guilty or doubtful about how they got there.

Daniel explained that while he felt confident about the work he produced, he did not feel confident in his capabilities. When receiving compliments, he felt like “you’re complimenting me on my ways of producing it, instead of on me.”

Generative AI can help students perform at a higher level. It can also quietly weaken the learning process that doctoral education is designed to build.

Based on your research, what do you wish faculty better understood about international doctoral students’ use of generative AI?

International doctoral students carry pressures faculty do not always see. Many write academically in a second or third language, while also navigating unwritten rules, visa status and financial pressure.

Within that context, students use AI more thoughtfully than they get credit for. Neha chooses not to use AI for academic writing at all, saying she needs this time to develop those skills herself. Aiza put it simply: “I want the thinking to be mine.” Felipe said: “You need to do the thinking. You need to do the work.”

What can universities do to support responsible AI use without making students feel surveilled, punished or afraid to ask questions?

Participants were clear about what they needed. Ayana said AI has become “inevitable” and asked for guidelines to match that reality. Tendai echoed what many wanted:

“People were looking for guidance, the rules or the policies or the ethics of it.”

What they asked for was open conversation, clear expectations and safe spaces to talk about AI, not more detection. Universities that provide that clarity build trust. When they stay silent or lead with bans, students end up figuring out the ethics on their own.

Karly Rakhim.

A native of Almaty, Kazakhstan, Karly Rakhim is pursuing her PhD in higher education in the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy. She hopes her work will inspire institutions to create more inclusive and compassionate learning environments where every student can thrive.

Editor’s note: The names of the student participants have been changed to protect their privacy as part of research study protocols.