This talk examines the dynamics around engagement and ways of knowing of specific communities (often marginalized or under-studied), whether it be migrants or refugees, indigenous communities in remote and isolated regions, or young Muslims negotiating their identities in a post 9/11 world. In conducting research with these communities, my consideration is one that adheres to a methodology of refusing the silencing of certain voices in society. Taken together, these strands of research expand on the meanings and values of inclusion, ask whether a diversity mindset can foster sustainable change, and probe and unsettle the rigidity of the scholarly and pedagogical systems in which we operate.